Diny’s Jewelers



From the phone greeting to walking out their door with my gold wedding band back on my finger, service was fabulous! The work done to put the two pieces back together again was PERFECT  after having the ring cut off due to a finger injury.   Seamless, polished, and beautiful again!  Mav :>

Google User

Diny’s has made me a life long customer.  I had not been able to wear my wedding ring for about 2 years and went to multiple locations to get it sized up 2 sizes.  I was told NO.  Diny’s was able to size both my engagement ring and wedding band up 2 sizes and get it back on my finger in about a week.  I could not say enough about how happy they have made me.  Nick was amazing in helping me get my ring sized.  I will be going back to Diny’s for future jewelry needs!

Google User

You are treated extremely well in this family-owned jewelry store. We spent a little more on our rings but those are the things that last the longest so we wanted to go with the best.

Wedding Wire User

Thanks Diny’s Jewelers for helping make this happen!!!  It’s more than I could imagine!!!

Ashley Rose

I recently took about 20 pieces of heirloom jewelry and my wedding ring to Diny’s to have appraised. Most of the jewelry was appraised in 2009 (another state) as part of a family estate and a few were given to us by one of other mothers. Before selecting Diny’s I first did a lot of online research about what credentials to look for when seeking an appraisal. Of all the jewelers in the Madison area, Pete Diny is the only one who is both a Graduate Gemologist (GIA) and a Master Graduate Gemologist Appraiser (IJO). I needed someone who was knowledgable of old jade, vintage watches and pearls. When first interviewing Pete I said that I had a lot of old jewelry but I didn’t know if the pieces were costume or real. He said to bring everything in and he would be happy to look through what I had. I set up an appointment. We had agreed that he would only do a formal appraisal on jewelry that he thought would come in with an insurance value over $1000. He looked at all the pieces I brought in, separating out the costume jewelry and the pieces above and below the minimum. He was very pleasant to work with, respectful of the pieces and extremely familiar with older jewelry and took pictures of the pieces to be appraised. I could tell right away that he really enjoys looking at and appraising estate jewelry. I was given a copy of the picture of the collection he would appraise to take with me. I brought the pieces in on a MOnday and the appraisals were ready before Friday. I knew that I could have paid a lot less to have the jewelry appraised somewhere else. I had some appraised at another long time jeweler a few years ago but the appraisals came back with no reference images on the write up. Each Diny’s appraisal includes a picture of item – which I appreciated as some of my jewelry is very similar in appearance. Diny’s also offers a lifetime appraisal so I can bring in a piece anytime to have it reappraised. Great. Because the value of gold has increased 4x from 2009, I was pleasantly surprised that the value of the pieces appraised in 2009 increased at least 4x. On MOnday I contacted my insurance company to increase the insurance value of my wedding ring since I enjoy wearing it. Having the lifetime appraisal policy is well worth the cost of the appraisals. I felt confident that I received a professional appraisal and that my jewelry was in good hands at all times. I would highly recommend Diny’s Jewelers.

Mae H.

I found a ring design on Pinterest and fell in love. I wanted to reuse my own jewelry so it would have a deeper connection to me. Not only did Diny’s craft my new ring; they spent lots of time and effort going over all of my wants and desires, making sure I would get exactly what i wanted. This was no easy task and I know they labored over this because their skill craftsmanship shows. Now i have a ring that i can treasure forever. Thank you (to everyone on your staff) for being so compassionate, knowledgeable and thoughtful.

Megan Ennis

Diny’s sized my wedding ring 12 years ago and recently brought it back to its original brilliance with a small makeover and sizing. It is as beautiful as the day my husband gave it to me. I almost cried! Thank you so much.

Mindy Roys

I love Diny’s jewelry. It’s high quality and they make you feel so special when you are in the store.

Ellen Mary Utter

Diny’s sized my wedding ring 12 years ago and recently brought it back to its original brilliance with a small makeover and sizing. It is as beautiful as the day my husband gave it to me. I almost cried! Thank you so much.

Mindy Roys

So grateful for the wonderful experience in a warm atmosphere. Thank you Beverly, & Nick for the great job and Pete & Hannah’s kind words of support. Your beautiful store and friendly knowledgeable team made our experience exceptional. We love DINY’S.

Michaelle Ramseth-Eeg

Diny’s Jewelers is a family owned jewelry business located in Middleton. You either meet one or both of the owner’s when you come into Diny’s. They do repairs, appraisals, custom work, special orders and hand-pick every piece that is in their inventory, Lowest prices possible. Go into Diny’s today to explore the knowledgeable, friendly, and educated staff that you can trust, you won’t regret it! 🙂

Hannah Kaeser

My husband did an amazing job picking out my wedding ring and band set, I am in LOVE with my set. The staff did an unbelievably awesome job helping him pick out the perfect one.
It’s been almost 4 years now since he asked me to be his wife. Within that time I’ve had my ring sized twice and just recently sent it back in for damage endured to the prongs (literally ripped them right off my diamond while injuring hand at work). Every time I have had any service done on my ring the staff at Diny’s have been incredible. Not only do they do an amazing job but they also do it in a VERY timely manner. Everything is always done and ready before the promised time which I love because I feel like I’m always forgetting something, or that I have lost something without my rings, and it seems they truely understand this. Can’t say enough about them and the amazing job they do. Thank you Diny’s Jewelers

Karen Goldade

I brought in a bag of items I inherited from my mom. Not knowing much about jewelry myself, I was looking for an honest assessment of the pieces I had and what to do with them. Pete was very helpful, examining all of the items and letting me know what was valuable and what was costume. He made good recommendations regarding what I should consider having appraised, and he cleaned many of the other items. He was able to reset a single earring of my mom’s (one of my favorites that I remember her wearing) into a pendant. I will return to Diny’s as I was treated as a valued customer and dealt with honestly and fairly.

Margaret L

I recently purchased an engagement ring at Diny’s and was very impressed with their service and knowledge of the products. I was explained that I was looking for a very traditional ring and they were able to tell me about all the possible options within the setting. Walking through the door I did not know too much about diamonds, but now, after going through the process I am much more knowledgeable. I worked closely through Sara who explained the different cuts, clarity, color and carats. She was very patient as I made multiple trips back to the store while considering different diamonds. The ring was an absolute perfect fit for our perfect moment when my fiancée said yes! I visited a few other stores before coming to Diny’s and my search ended there because I could tell they truly wanted what was best for me and my fiancée. The service, knowledge and expertise that was offered from Sara, Pete and Bev far exceeded my expectations and I would highly recommend looking to them for any type of jewelry needs!

The Knot User

They did an amazing job restoring my grandma’s engagement ring for me, and my wedding band. They were always in communication while the work was being done, which I really appreciated. Will continue to use them for my jewelry! –Facebook Review

Kelly M